My husband lives in my $650K home. He complains about paying ‘rent’ of $2,000 a month — and wants to use that money to trade stocks

Dear Quentin,

My partner and I have been married for two years. We both earn 6 figures, whilst I make considerably additional than him.

We are both equally in our mid-40s, and this is our 2nd marriage. We have a prenuptial arrangement and hold all of our income different. When we married, he moved into my dwelling with me and my 15-12 months-old child.

He pays me $2,000 for each thirty day period for all dwelling expenditures, except groceries. I possess the residence outright, and the expenditures are roughly $30,000 a 12 months. He continually badgers me that it is unfair he is paying out rent. I guess he thinks he ought to be spending considerably less or almost nothing. 

He states he does not want to shell out rent, as he is not receiving anything at all in return and the cash is squandered. He thinks I am producing revenue from him. I have offered to let him acquire 50 % of the property, and he has no desire in executing that.  

‘He complains that all my stuff is right here, and mostly the residence is mine. I have available to go so we can get a spot jointly.’

He wants to hold his funds in the lender so that he can make cash by investments this sort of as trading. Is the total he is paying out good? Must I be supplying a discounted on housing? We are living in a $650,000 home.

He complains that all my things is here, and mainly the residence is mine. I have presented to move so we can get a spot alongside one another, and he states that is not an alternative unless I want to put all the income up front and invest in the house.

His reasoning is that he wishes to use his funds for trading and investments. I could incorporate that throughout the last 4 a long time that we have identified each individual other, he has not experienced any beneficial investments to report on his tax return.

What do you think is a good compromise in this article? How do I get him to recognize that I am not using edge of him, but that he is a grown man and must be in a position and eager to pay out his share with out complaining?


The House owner and 2nd Wife

Dear Property owner,

1 man’s rent is yet another woman’s costs. 

You have recognized every other for four many years, you have been married for two, and you are each on your next marriages. I assist your decision to have independent lender accounts, at least for now, and to have some arrangement wherever your spouse pays his way. He pays extra than 50 percent of the expenses on your property, but you have also expended $650,000 on a house and worked really hard to pay back it off by your mid-40s. 

‘His month-to-month residing expenses never go up, and he life in a large property. Which is a sweet offer.’

I presume you experienced a discussion about funds before you married, and you jointly agreed to this $2,000. Provided that your partner needs to pay fewer so he can engage in the stock sector — and has dismissed your recommendation of contributing to a residence that you jointly possess — I imagine he’s getting a great discount. His regular living charges never ever go up, and he life in a large household.

It’s tough to say whether $2,000 is far too much without having being aware of where by you are living, and how substantially your husband helps make, but assuming he would have problem renting a a person-bedroom condominium for the very same selling price, it is a sweet deal. On top of that, he needs all of the gains and none of the pitfalls. If the foundations will need underpinning, you spend. If the roof desires replacing, that’s your section.

There is also a double regular hovering in excess of his request for you to minimize him of his dwelling fees. What belongs to you is his to stay in free of charge, but all that extra income for investments belongs to him? It’s a little bit prosperous for him to chastise you for performing 1 matter, and then blithely explain to you he needs to do a model of the similar factor. Which is a double common. No sale.

Also study: Jamie Dimon insists his employees return to the workplace — here’s why that is a bit loaded

You can e-mail The Moneyist with any money and ethical queries linked to coronavirus at, and abide by Quentin Fottrell on Twitter.

By emailing your issues, you concur to getting them released anonymously on MarketWatch. By distributing your tale to Dow Jones & Company, the publisher of MarketWatch, you understand and concur that we may perhaps use your tale, or versions of it, in all media and platforms, together with by means of third events.

Test out the Moneyist private Facebook 
team, where we look for answers to life’s thorniest revenue concerns. Viewers generate in to me with all sorts of dilemmas. Article your concerns, convey to me what you want to know additional about, or weigh in on the newest Moneyist columns.

Much more from Quentin Fottrell:

Financial Planning Experts