Home sellers are realizing it’s no longer their housing market

The housing market has rapidly changed. Sellers, once in the driver’s seat at the start of the year, are much more accommodating to complete a home sale as borrowing costs skyrocket for buyers.

A growing number of home sellers have been forced to readjust their home prices in recent weeks. According to Redfin, an estimated 6.1% of homes for sale during the four weeks leading to June 19, asked for a price drop – a record high as far back as the data goes, through the start of 2015.

That comes as mortgage rates hit 5.70% last week and are nearly 2.5 percentage points higher than the beginning of 2022, relegating some buyers to the sidelines with busted budgets.

“If you overprice your home in any market, you’re going to feel resistance,” Lizy Hoeffer, owner and mortgage broker at Cross Country Mortgage LLC, said. “In the last three years, sellers have been able to get basically whatever they want for their house. We’re just not in a market like that right now.”

‘Buyer budgets don’t stretch as far as they used to’

The dream of homeownership is slipping out of grasp for many would-be buyers as costs rise.

“Homeowners thinking about moving should know that while recent sellers have enjoyed favorable housing conditions that included high prices and fast sales, the tide is shifting,” Realtor.com Chief Economist Danielle Hale, told Yahoo Money. “Higher rates and home prices mean that homebuyer budgets don’t stretch as far as they used to.”

According to Realtor.com, rising mortgage rates have increased the monthly mortgage payment on a median-priced home an estimated 60% more than last year. The median monthly mortgage payment has jumped by $513 from the start of the year through May, according to a recent report from MBA.

For instance, in the most populated county of Washington State, King County, the average price is over $1 million, according to Adriana Perezchica, real estate broker and owner of Via Real Estate Group. Despite the challenges, Latinos there – which comprise a large portion of her clientele – are buying in the outskirts for an average of $550,000.

Story continues

“Most of my clients are first-time buyers, with no knowledge or very little understanding on buying a property. “The majority work in the construction, labor and the hospitality industry,” Perezchica said. “They dream of owning a home and are persuaded to buy because of the high cost of rent, however affordability is the main factor preventing them from purchasing a home.”

Real estate agents leave a home for sale during a broker open house in San Francisco, California. (Credit: by Justin Sullivan, Getty Images)

Rising borrowing costs erode buyer confidence

Other signs point to more reluctant homebuyers.

“Demand is still strong, but not nearly as much as three or six months ago when the market was at a feverish pace,” President of WSFS Mortgage, Jeffrey Ruben, told Yahoo Money. “We would see multiple offers, sometimes 10, 12 or 15 people bidding on the same house. We’re not seeing those stories today.”

As borrowing costs swell across the country, buyer confidence has ebbed. Approximately, 57.8% of home offers written by Redfin agents faced competition on seasonally adjusted basis in May, the lowest level recorded since February 2021. That’s down from a revised 60.9% one month prior, according to Redfin. It’s also a decline from 67.8% in April – and marks the fourth consecutive drop in bidding-war activity.

“The frenzied rush to find a home and lock-in historically-low interest rates seen during the past two-plus years has been relegated to the history books,” George Ratiu, manager of economic research at Realtor.com, said in a prepared statement. “The result is a softening housing demand, which comes as many homeowners are embracing the new normal and listing their homes for sale.”

Only about 8% of Broward households can afford a single-family home at the median sale price. Experts worry how that might affect the area’s service and hospitality workforces — major pillars of the local economy. (Credit: Mike Stocker, Sun Sentinel/Tribune News Service via Getty Images)

Contracts to purchase previously owned homes rebounded in May after declining for six straight months, likely due to a brief pullback in rates last month. The National Association of Realtors Pending Home Sales index, rose 0.7% as home shoppers in the Northeast region took advantage of the pause in mortgage rates surge.

Still, homebuyers face harsh affordability conditions, with the median listing price of $447,000 — pending home sales were down 13.6% from a year ago.

The impact of rising mortgage rates and home prices has effectively cooled the housing market. Redfin data showed touring activity as of June 19, was down 6% from the start of the year compared to a 24% increase a year earlier. Mortgage applications were down 10% from a year prior, and fewer people searched for ‘homes for sale’ on Google during the week ending June 18, down 14% from a year ago.

“Typical first-time buyers are still in very short supply,” Len Kiefer, deputy chief economist for Freddie Mac, told Yahoo Money. “Now you’ve got these super high rates, so it’s a big pinch for those first time buyers. Still there’s a very strong demand despite some challenges.”

A sale pending sign is posted in front of a home for sale on March 18, 2022 in San Rafael, California. Sales of existing homes dropped 3.4% in May, as mortgage rates top topped 5%. Month-over-month, sales declined in three out of four regions in the US. (Credit: Justin Sullivan, Getty Images)

A sale pending sign is posted in front of a home for sale on March 18, 2022 in San Rafael, California. Sales of existing homes dropped 3.4% in May, as mortgage rates top topped 5%. Month-over-month, sales declined in three out of four regions in the US. (Credit: Justin Sullivan, Getty Images)

Inventory levels remain a concern

Make no mistake: The home buyer pool may be shrinking, but it’s still not a buyers’ market.

According to Joe Castillo, designated managing broker, co-owner of REMAX Mi Casa in Chicago, purchase activity was up 26% from a year ago in his brokerage – but a lack of available listings for sale has slowed housing activity.

“Our biggest concern at the moment, just as it was for the last two years, is the lack of inventory,” Castillo said. “We have hundreds of pre-approved buyers looking for homes that do not exist due to a lack of financeable for-sale homes.”

Other indicators signal a competitive market still.

Redfin data showed some 34% of homes that went under contract accepted an offer within one week of hitting the market, down 36% from a year ago. Meanwhile, 48% of homes went under contract within the first two weeks on the market, slightly down from 50% a year ago.

Despite surging rates, homes for sale stayed an average 17 days on the market. According to Redfin, that’s up from the record low of 15 days posted in May and early June – signaling fast paced buyer demand. Some 55% of homes sold above list price, Redfin reported, up from 53% a year ago.

“Buyers are very frustrated,” Nadia Evangelou, senior economist and director of forecasting for NAR, told Yahoo Money. “It’s very competitive and many first-time homebuyers cannot find a home and can’t compete with existing homeowners with all cash offers from their built equity. However, with rising mortgage rates everybody is expected to be impacted.”

Gabriella is a personal finance reporter at Yahoo Money. Follow her on Twitter @__gabriellacruz.

Read the latest personal finance trends and news from Yahoo Money.

Follow Yahoo Finance on Twitter, Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, Flipboard, and LinkedIn.